For three decades now, The Honest Lawyer has stood a little apart from Nelson’s hospitality scene – quite literally, on its own patch of reclaimed land in Monaco – and figuratively too. With its unmistakable Olde English character, The Honest Lawyer is the sort of place locals point out to visitors with pride and affection. This year marks 30 years since the doors first opened, and the milestone offers a chance to reflect on how a once-questioned idea became one of the region’s most enduring establishments.
The Honest Lawyer was established in 1995 by Mike Gepp, who had a clear vision: to recreate an Olde English Cornish pub at the edge of Tasman Bay. At the time, the idea raised more than a few eyebrows.
As owner Chris Baillie explains, the project faced “dubious objections and a lot of public scepticism” before consent was finally granted.
Built largely on reclaimed land, the pub was a bold move for its era and one that Chris doubts would be possible under today’s rules. Yet once built, the character and charm of the place quickly won people over.
Walking through The Honest Lawyer today, it’s easy to see why. Low ceilings, exposed beams, open fires and cosy nooks give it an atmosphere that feels familiar. Outside, the grounds open into something far more expansive: lawns, gardens, and a relaxed atmosphere that has made it a favourite for families, dog-owners, and anyone keen to linger over a drink in the sun.
Chris became part of The Honest Lawyer story in 2010, when he purchased the business with a close friend. At the time, he was still working for the New Zealand Police and took on the role of a silent partner.
“It was a pretty impulsive purchase,” he admits. “But owning a pub sounded like fun!”
Two years later, in 2012, he became sole director, stepping fully into the challenges and rewards of running such a distinctive venue.
Those challenges, he’s quick to point out, have been significant. Despite long careers in teaching, policing, and even dabbling in politics, Chris says business ownership has been the most stressful of all.
“When I first bought the business, a good mate, who is a businessman, said, ‘If running a business was easy, everyone would be doing it’, and he was right. It’s been a huge learning curve for me. I’ve been a teacher for 22 years, a Policeman for 14 and dabbled with politics, but owning a business is far more stressful than any of them.”
Still, the journey has been deeply satisfying.
What sets The Honest Lawyer apart, Chris believes, is its sheer versatility.
“The Honest is a venue for everyone. We have a large outdoor area where dogs and kids are welcome, a number of rooms perfect for functions of various sizes and a fantastic open area and Barn for wedding ceremonies and celebrations. We also have 13 rooms, a great kitchen team, fantastic bar staff and 13 beers on tap. We really are a one-stop shop!”
Music has also become a defining thread in The Honest Lawyer’s story, thanks largely to Chris’s own passion.
"I wanted The Honest to be part of the Nelson music scene. I think that’s been achieved with being the base for Tasman Bays Blues Club, and a close association with The Nelson Jazz Club and the famous ukulele group The Plinkers. We have regular music on Sunday afternoons and other times when we can.”
Then there are the smaller, recurring moments that truly capture the spirit of the place. The Honest Lawyer Fun-Run, held on Monday nights since 2011, is one such tradition – equal parts fitness, social gathering and excuse for a post-run drink. It’s events like these, alongside the familiar faces of long-time regulars, that give the pub its strong sense of community.
Looking back over 30 years, Chris says he’s most proud of simply getting through the tough times. The COVID-19 pandemic and its aftermath were particularly challenging, testing both resilience and resolve.
Keeping the doors open while employing up to 36 staff at any one time was no small feat. For many local businesses, survival itself has been an achievement, and The Honest Lawyer is no exception.
But as for the future, Chris is optimistic, saying, “There’s a sense that confidence is returning, not just among customers but across the business community.” While he’s keeping details close to his chest, he hints at “some exciting changes coming up” designed to keep the venue customer-focused and relevant as it moves into its fourth decade.
After 30 years, The Honest Lawyer is so much more than just a pub. It’s a meeting place, a music venue, a wedding backdrop, a stop-in for travellers and a second home for many locals.
Its survival and success rest not on bricks, beams and beer taps, but on the relationships built within its walls and across its lawns. As Nelson continues to grow and change, one thing feels reassuringly constant: The Honest Lawyer will still be there, pint poured, fire lit, welcoming everyone in!
To book a table, visit RESERVATIONS
