
TONI EVANS
For Blessing Biran, automatically generated AI search summaries raises a simple question: why are resources being used to create something she never asked for?
The Motueka woman’s 'No Automatic AI Overview' petition calls for an end to unsolicited AI Overviews and for online AI functions to require users to opt in.
“I believe that being given something that we didn’t ask for, many times a day, is not OK, especially when there is an environmental cost.”
Blessing noticed Google's AI Overview appearing above the usual website results earlier this year. As someone who does a lot of research, she encounters it many times a day and finds it not only annoying but also concerning.
She's noticed how easy it is for people to simply accept AI Overview's work, and she is increasingly worried about the expansion of the data centres that support it.
For Blessing, the issue reaches beyond the search screen. Land, water and electricity are being used to generate material people may neither need nor want, yet encounter every day without asking for it.
She questions the value of consuming those resources to produce content commonly described as "AI slop", while people, particularly children, face the challenge of distinguishing genuine material from artificially generated content.
The natural world, she says, “is our provider and home and needs our voice, as it has none”.
Rather than attempting to address every ethical concern surrounding AI, Blessing is campaigning for a change to the default setting for AI functions, something she sees as both concrete and achievable.
"I believe strongly in freedom of choice and personal autonomy," she says.
"If people want to use AI, they are welcome to use it. But I believe the default for AI functions should be 'OFF' and people should have to choose it every time."
Launched in September, the petition is closing in on 500 signatures, Blessing says, despite limited time to promote it. She describes the response from people she has spoken to as overwhelmingly positive.
Her next steps include raising awareness and finding volunteers in Motueka and elsewhere in New Zealand willing to collect signatures at their local markets.
Hosted on OurActionStation, the petition is addressed to the ministers responsible for communications and media, regulation, and consumer affairs.
Blessing hopes readers will consider her proposal and, if they agree, sign and share it.
To read and sign the petition, visit our.actionstation.org.nz/petitions/ban-the-automatic-ai-overview or search OurActionStation for "No Automatic AI Overview".