
The decision to back a new build on Church St for a combined civic hub and library over refurbishing the existing Civic House on Trafalgar St has created division amongst elected members. Nelson Mayor Nick Smith and Deputy Mayor Pete Rainey hold conflicting views on the best way forward. They share their perspectives.
‘Civic House the common sense solution’ - Nick Smith, Nelson Mayor
I backed the refurbishment of Civic House over a new build in Church St because it is the commonsense solution, best value for money and due to its overwhelming public support.
Civic House is a structurally sound building with the best access to parking and public transport.
It’s the least-expensive option and we are in a cost-of-living crisis. Civic House provides 1000 square metres, or 15% more space for $15 million less.
The council’s comprehensive 28-page consultation document outlined three options with upfront costs: Refurbishing Civic House, $73.3m, building new on leasehold land in Collingwood St, $74.1m and $88.2m for buying properties and building new in Church St.
The public response was phenomenal with 1417 submissions compared with 360 for our last Annual Plan consultation and 880 for controversial Plan Change 29.
The result was emphatic with 62.5% public support for Civic House compared with 24.5% for Church St.
Ignoring these submissions makes a mockery of council’s consultation processes and feeds public disillusionment with democracy.
The argument that refurbishing Civic House is too risky makes no sense. Comparisons to heritage buildings such as the Wellington Town Hall, opened in 1904, are disingenuous.
Civic House was opened in 1983 and dozens of buildings that age have been successfully refurbished.
It is argued we need to build new as the disruption of refurbishing Civic House will be too stressful for the council. It’s part of life.
Council imposes huge disruption on others with upgrades such as Bridge to Better.
Is council to build new again in 40 years when the Church St building needs its services and fitout upgraded? We are not so wealthy a city or country that we can walk away from buildings that need a refit because we would like the new and shiny.
We should also practice what we preach on reuse and recycling. Demolishing three buildings in Church St and building new is less environmentally sound. It also displaces existing businesses such as Tern Coffee House, Yogis and the Nelson English Centre.
Advocates for the new Church St building say it will revitalise the city.
The reality is that it will simply shift people using the library and council services from one part of the city to another.
Civic House is also the most flexible solution in the face of any future changes to local government or amalgamation.
A multi-storey building is more adaptable in that individual floors can be tenanted as council did with Inland Revenue.
This is the largest project our Council has embarked on in decades. It’s too easy to spend other people’s money. We need the least-cost solution and we need to take the public with us.
‘Let’s build something Nelson can be proud of’ - Pete Rainey, Deputy Mayor of Nelson
I love Nelson. Its character, its people, its creativity and the wonderful place we call home.
But I’ve lived here long enough to watch great opportunities slip through our fingers. Good ideas discussed for years, then delayed, watered down or abandoned. Our new Civic Hub and Library is a classic example. We’ve talked about replacing our library for nearly 20 years. Meanwhile, Blenheim has built its impressive library and art gallery, Picton has a wonderful community hub, and Greymouth has invested in a new library. Why shouldn’t Nelson have something just as good, or better? That’s why I strongly support council’s decision to pursue a new library and community hub in Church St. I’m happy to own that decision.
Call it Pete’s palace if you like. But it’s not for me - it’s for you and future generations of Nelsonians.
Let’s talk about the money
Every dollar matters, and council must spend wisely. The Church St project now has a confirmed $78 million cap, more than $10 million below the original $88.2 million estimate.
Council already has $68.4 million in its Long Term Plan for a library and civic facility. We’ve been budgeting for this investment for years.
The consultation figures showed Church St costing an average residential ratepayer 90 cents a week more than redeveloping Civic House, at the projected peak.That used the old $88.2 million estimate. With the $78 million cap, the difference should be smaller, although updated rates calculations are needed. We’re making the most of an investment already planned. And these aren’t identical buildings.
One option means spending tens of millions adapting a 1970s office building, working around existing columns, ceiling heights and layout. The other offers a purpose-built facility for the next 50 years and beyond.
Just imagine the possibilities
Picture a welcoming building linking Church St, Trafalgar St, the Museum, Cathedral Steps and our hospitality precinct. Children discovering books. Students studying. Families meeting. Older people catching up with friends. Visitors exploring our city.
A place for exhibitions, performances, community events, learning, technology and activities we haven’t dreamed up yet.It should be a place open to everyone, where a family’s income never determines whether they can take part in our city’s life.
Nelson has so much going for it
Private developers are backing Nelson. The Morrison precinct is progressing. Bridge to Better is transforming our city centre. There’s exciting potential on our waterfront. Together, these projects point towards a confident, attractive, thriving Nelson. Council should back that confidence with investment of its own.
I’ve watched Nelson miss too many opportunities. We don’t need another cancelled project or expensive compromise that falls short of what our city deserves. Saying no is easy. Great cities are built by people with imagination, confidence and a willingness to invest in the future. If local government amalgamation eventually happens, that’s another reason to strengthen Nelson as the natural centre of the Top of the South.
This is about the next generation
I know not everyone agrees with the decision. That’s democracy. Eight councillors supported it because we believed it offered the strongest long-term opportunity for Nelson.
What’s your view? Email sara@topsouthmedia.co.nz to share your thoughts and have them printed in next week’s Nelson Weekly.